“Should I buy a home?” Home prices have soared, interest rates remain sticky, and many first-time buyers feel like they’re watching the train pull out of the station. If you’ve saved for years but can’t afford a home nearby, should you stretch to buy (maybe hours away) or invest that cash instead?
In this episode, we get into the psychology, math, and lifestyle tradeoffs behind the “buy now or wait” dilemma. Plus, we unpack total return, explain when umbrella insurance is worth it, and share the most important lessons to teach teenagers about money.
Listener Questions in This Episode
Anonymous (aka “Lydia”) (3:26): ”I saved six figures for a down payment, but houses are still out of reach. Do I buy a home now, rent forever, or invest the cash instead?”
Lydia, an Australian listener, spent eight years saving to buy a home, only to find that every property within reach feels like a compromise. Sky-high prices close to work, or long commutes for affordability. It’s a crossroads that many listeners can relate to: does owning mean freedom, or does it just tie you down?
We explore three key ideas: how to separate fear from opportunity, why “starter-home-turned-rental” plans often backfire, and how to measure the real cost of lost time when you move hours from where you work and live.
Ultimately, it’s about aligning your money with your life design, not the housing headlines.
Anonymous (aka “Aristotle”) (25:38): “My ETF is up 10% and yields 3%. Is my net return 13%?”
It’s a common question for anyone tracking their investments. We unpack the difference between total return and your personal rate of return, and why those two numbers rarely match. You’ll learn what actually drives performance – and how to read your brokerage dashboard like a pro investor.
Joel (34:44): “Umbrella insurance; do we need it and how much?”
If you own a home, drive a car, or rent out a property, you’re exposed to more liability than you might realize. We break down how umbrella insurance works, when it’s essential, and how much coverage makes sense. It’s one of the cheapest ways to protect your wealth from a financial wipeout.
Julia (48:13): “I’m building a high-school personal finance course. Should I cover insurance or credit?”
When teaching teenagers about money, where do you even begin? We explore why understanding decision-making (opportunity cost, compounding, and how to filter bad financial advice) matters more than memorizing credit scores or insurance terms. This one’s for parents, teachers, and anyone who wants to raise financially confident kids.
Key Takeaways
- Buying from FOMO (fear of missing out) is rarely a winning strategy. Let your lifestyle goals, not market panic, drive big decisions.
- Separate your home decisions from your investment decisions. A hybrid “live-then-rent” plan often underperforms on both fronts.
- Total return includes both price changes and income, but your broker’s “personal rate of return” shows the truest number.
- Umbrella insurance adds millions in protection for relatively little cost. Bundle it with your home and auto for simplicity.
- Teach teens the “why” behind money choices before the “what.” Understanding tradeoffs and compounding beats memorizing rules.
Resources & Links
- Afford Anything Community: Join the conversation, especially if you have insights about housing and investing from Australia.
- Afford Anything Newsletter: Fresh money ideas, First Friday deep dives, and behind-the-scenes updates delivered weekly.
- Find more Real Estate topics here.
Glossary
- Total Return: Price appreciation plus dividends or interest earned on an investment.
- Cap Rate: A rental property’s annual net income divided by its purchase price.
- Umbrella Insurance: Extra liability coverage ($1–5M+) that sits on top of home and auto limits.
- Opportunity Cost: The value of what you give up when choosing one option over another.
Chapters
Note: Timestamps will vary on individual listening devices based on dynamic advertising segments. The provided timestamps are approximate and may be several minutes off due to changing ad lengths.
(4:14) First caller Anonymous Lydia: should I buy now or invest my down payment?
(8:23) The emotional trap of FOMO and rising prices
(11:45) Why “live there now, rent it later” rarely works
(22:14) The hidden cost of long commutes and lifestyle tradeoffs
(25:38) Second caller Anonymous Aristotle: how do I calculate my true investment return?
(34:44) Third caller Joel: Is umbrella insurance worth it and how much should I buy?
(48:13) Fourth caller – Julia: what high schoolers should learn first about money
If this episode helped you rethink a housing or investing decision, share it with a friend who’s feeling stuck between renting and buying. Subscribe to the Afford Anything Podcast for smart, grounded conversations that help you make better choices with money, time, and life
Thanks to our sponsors!
Policy Genius
Secure your family’s future with Policygenius. Head to policygenius.com to compare life insurance quotes from top companies and see how much you could save.
Quince
Find your fall staples at Quince. Go to quince.com/paula for free shipping on your order and 365-day returns.
Shopify
Sign up for your one month, one dollar per month trial period and start selling today at shopify.com/paula
Indeed
If you’re looking for amazing talent to bolster your team, you need Indeed. Go to indeed.com/paula and start hiring with a seventy-five dollar sponsored job credit.
