Should a 48-year-old New Yorker who’s retiring next year buy more rental properties?
Should a Michigan-based first-time homebuyer use an FHA loan to buy a duplex for $135,000 that rents for $1,800 per month?
Should a 40-year-old music professor who owns a duplex transfer his property into an LLC?
Should a New Jersey condo owner sell her unit as For Sale by Owner?
And should a woman who’s anxious about owning her own rental properties dive into real estate crowdfunding deals instead?
I answer these five rental property questions in today’s podcast episode.
Here are the details:
Matthew asks:
Last fall, I closed on a duplex. This purchase occurred before we started an LLC, so the property is under my name instead of the business. I know I could change the ownership with a quit claim deed, but I’ve heard there may be complications with the mortgage lender when going this route. Can you give any advice on how to transfer a rental property into an LLC?
I also have two related questions:
- I recently purchased a $1M umbrella insurance policy; I’ve heard that some people use an umbrella policy instead of an LLC for rentals. Are you for or against this?
- If the rental is not under an LLC, will I still have the same tax advantages for owning a rental property?
Julie asks:
I own a 4-unit property that I purchased 11 years ago, and my husband and I househack our primary residence, renting out a portion of it on Airbnb. I’m 48 years old, and I plan to retire in spring 2020. I love being a landlord, and we’re constantly looking to purchase other properties in cheaper areas. (We live in NYC.)
However, our cash position isn’t the greatest, and with my retirement date nearing, I’m wondering: should we buy additional rental properties? Or should we wait and save more money, rather than tapping into our equity?
Also, do you have any thoughts on where we should invest?
Shannon asks:
I’ve owned my condo for three years, and I’ve been president of the condo HOA for two of those years. I’ve overseen the majority of the renovations in this building, including a massive remodel inside my own unit.
Despite the time and energy I’ve put into upgrading my condo, I’ve decided that I’d like to sell my condo this spring. The local housing market is booming, and I’d like to relocate closer to my family in Florida.
Since I have so much knowledge about this building and my own property, I think it might make sense for me to sell on my own, rather than pay the fees associated with having a realtor.
Do you have any feedback or suggestions regarding the pros and cons or risks and benefits of pursuing a for-sale-by-owner route?
Brianne asks:
Do you have any thoughts on syndicated real estate deals? I want to invest in real estate as passively as possible, but I wasn’t sure if syndicated deals were a good idea. What are your thoughts?
Eric asks:
I’m looking at buying a duplex for $135,000. One side rents for $800, and my girlfriend and I will live in the other side. If we moved out, we could rent that side for $1,000. I’d like to buy this duplex with an FHA loan, putting 3.5 percent down, and my goal is to stop paying for mortgage insurance as quickly as possible.
I recently repaid nearly $40,000 in student loans, although I’ve had to slow down on the last of my student loan repayments in order to save money for this duplex purchase. I also have a small emergency fund.
Do you think this duplex is a good deal? Should I get an FHA loan? And the owner wants to sell the property to me as an FSBO deal; what do I need to know?
I answer these five real estate questions in today’s podcast episode. Enjoy!


Thanks to our sponsors!
Policygenius
Policygenius is the easy way to get life insurance. In minutes, you can compare quotes from top insurers to find the coverage you need, at a price you can afford. No matter how much – or how little – you know about life insurance, you can find the right policy at Policygenius.
Gusto
Gusto makes payroll, benefits, and HR easy for modern small businesses. In fact, 72% of customers spend less than 5 minutes to run payroll! If you sign up at gusto.com/paula, you’ll receive 3 months free once you run your first payroll.
Blinkist
Busy, but love to read and learn? Blinkist is the only app that takes the best key takeaways from thousands of nonfiction books and condenses them down into just 15 minutes. You can start a free 7-day trial when you join at blinkist.com/paula.

Rothy’s are great for travel!
Rothy’s shoes are stylish, sustainable, and comfortable for every day wear, anywhere. They come in three styles, their lineup is updated often, and I love that they make flats from recycled plastic water bottles! If you want to order a pair and get free shipping (with no minimum), enter the code paula at checkout on rothys.com.
Brianne MacLellan
Paula, thank you for answering my question! Of course your answer is obvious but not until you said it (lol). You are brilliant.
Because I am just learning about real estate and I am a bit Type A I become anxious about failing. So I thought a syndicated deal sort of lessens my responsibility, but you are so right I have to do my due diligence no matter what, maybe even more so.
To answer your question I am interested in real estate because I want to create passive income and cash flow. I do believe real estate is the best way to build that. My fear and anxieties comes from my lack of knowledge and experience but that only way to get past that is to keep reading and researching and of course taking action.
Thank you again!
Andrea
Love your podcast… have been listening since the beginning (through my iphone) just trying to listen online at work today and I just wanted to let you know that the pop ups on your site block the playback. It’s happened twice now and I’m only on the second question. I have to refresh the page in order to get the podcast to play again, and then find the spot where I was at. Kind of annoying and wanted to let you know!
Erin @ Team Afford Anything
Hi Andrea – I’m glad you’re enjoying the podcast, and thank you for letting us know about this! We underwent a new website redesign recently and this has gone undetected, so we appreciate the notice. (I actually listened to an episode via the site last night and didn’t run into this.)
If possible, it would help us to know which pop up is causing this to happen. I think we have two, so I want to make sure we focus on the right one. =)
Thanks again!
Jenn
Question regarding one of the tips – i.e. paying off the mortgage to improve cash flow…
I’ve considered this route w/ some of our rental properties – but on the flip side debate w/ myself on 1.) the equity sitting in the property then can’t be utilized elsewhere… 2.) I’ve also read/heard that when the house is paid off – it may be harder for to get a HELOC or refi for a cash out – esp for retirees where they can no longer show income (or perhaps the same level of income as before) … 3.) Also I’ve heard that once you pay off your mortgage – you lose the bank’s interest if you ever have an insurance claim and they no longer will need to come to bat with you to ensure the insurance payout meets the repair needs since they don’t have a stake in it anymore…
Are there any other good reasons to pay off that mortgage other than to improve cash flow?