|

The Crucial Reason Why You Must Think BIG

Money management can get really complicated — if you let it.

It's better to keep money management simple. Don't sweat the small stuff. Instead, think big picture for the most success with your finances.

People ask me all kinds of nuanced, nitty-gritty questions:

  • “Should I invest in Company XYZ, given that their price-to-book ratio is not up to recommended standards?”
  • “Which of these five developed-market small-cap value funds do you recommend?”
  • “Should I pay an early-withdrawal penalty to get out of an 18-month CD that pays 1.75 percent and use it to make an extra mortgage payment?”

My advice: Don’t sweat the small stuff.

Sometimes, it’s better to think less about percentages and more about actual dollar amounts.

We’re taught to conceptualize money management as a game of percentages: make sure you’re saving 20 percent of your income, make sure your pie of wealth is sliced in an age-appropriate way.

But sometimes people spend so much time thinking about percentages that they miss the fact that, at the end of the day, all that effort will yield them an extra $5 bucks.

Example: Say you have $2,000 in a 12-month Bank CD paying 1.75 percent. You realize that this will barely compensate for inflation, so you want to withdraw it and apply the cash toward an extra mortgage payment on your house.

Great idea. But here’s the problem: at the end of the day — after debating whether or not to do it, then going to the bank, meeting with a banker, filling out paperwork, closing the CD, paying the penalty, and writing the check to your mortgage company — you might not save that much.

If you’ve got 15 years remaining on a $100,000 fixed-rate mortgage at 5%, and you apply that extra $2,000 payment, you’ll save an extra $168 over the next 15-year life of your loan.

Does $168 sound like a lot? Then consider this:

  • Your effort probably took at least 3 hours.
  • You paid an early-withdrawal penalty. Let’s say that penalty was $18 (a little less than 1 percent). That means you saved only $150.
  • Based on historical inflation data, $150 today will be worth $101 in 15 years (based on 1994 – 2009 inflation data)
  • This means those 3 hours you worked will save you an inflation-adjusted $6.73 per year. And it’ll take you 15 years to get fully paid.

Would you really go through all that effort to save an extra $6.73 per year?

This is why you should not sweat the details.

At the end of the day, you’re better off spending your time investing in yourself, by:

  • Working on an entrepreneurial side-hustle
  • Exercising or cooking healthy
  • Spending time with family, friends, or spiritual activities
  • Doing something that MOVES the needle

You Might Also Like

  • | | |

    #668: Why Taking a Year Off Might Be Your Smartest Money Move, with David Bach

    We’re joined in-studio by David Bach, bestselling author of The Automatic Millionaire and The Latte Factor. He’s updated his most popular book (over two million copies sold) and this is his last big launch as he heads into retirement. Together, we wrestle with a problem our listeners know well: what happens when you’ve built the…

  • | |

    #665: Q&A: How Much Insurance Is Enough When You’re Protecting Your Wealth

    If you’ve ever stared at an insurance quote and wondered, “Is this really worth it?”, you’re not alone. Liability and umbrella policies can feel like an expensive mystery, especially when your net worth is growing and your risks are shifting. In today’s episode, we dig into a listener’s dilemma about soaring liability and umbrella insurance…

  • | | |

    #664: The Psychology of Sales, Discounts and Deals [GREATEST HITS]

    Today’s episode is a special rerun from the Afford Anything “greatest hits” vault, one that’s especially timely as we move through peak shopping season. Originally aired in January 2020, this conversation with behavioral economist Jeff Kreisler digs into the hidden psychology behind sales, discounts, so-called “free shipping,” and all the subtle emotional triggers that influence…

  • |

    The Real Price of That Thing You’re Thinking About Buying

    Remember the last thing you bought …. …. that’s now collecting dust in your closet? You thought it was a great deal, but now it’s just making you feel guilty? Yeah, me too. Here’s what nobody tells you about the price tag: it’s lying to you. That $500 treadmill isn’t really $500. It’s $500 plus the corner…

  • | | |

    #562: The Secret Psychology of Successful Negotiators, with Matt Schultz

    More than 90 percent of people who ask to get their credit card annual fee reduced are successful. Yet most people never ask.

    Why? They assume the answer will be no.

    Matt Schultz, the author of “Ask Questions, Save Money, Make More,” joins us to explain the psychology and tactics behind successful negotiation.

    The key insight: companies want to keep your business. Banks, employers, and service providers invest in long-term relationships because it’s more profitable than constantly finding new customers.

    This gives you more leverage than you might think.

    For credit cards, Schultz points out that calling the retention department directly (rather than general customer service) often leads to better results. He shares his own experience of getting his $600 annual fee cut in half just by making a yearly call.

    With mortgage negotiations, Schultz suggests getting quotes from 3-5 lenders on the same day, since rates change frequently. A quarter-point rate reduction on a $360,000 mortgage saves $20,000 over the life of the loan. The fees themselves can differ by $5,000 between lenders.

    When it comes to workplace negotiations, Schultz recommends keeping a weekly log of your accomplishments. Note both your regular duties and times you went above and beyond. This creates a strong foundation for salary discussions.

    The most effective negotiations frame requests as win-win scenarios. Instead of just asking for tuition reimbursement, explain how additional education will help you contribute more to the company. Rather than demanding a lower rent, offer to sign a longer lease that reduces the landlord’s vacancy risk.

    Schultz emphasizes building relationships during negotiations. The person at the call center has likely dealt with angry customers all day. Being pleasant and making a human connection can lead to better outcomes.

    The interview also covers negotiating with family members about money, choosing when to negotiate versus pay full price (like at charity shops or with small businesses), and how to time requests effectively.

    The common thread: success comes from understanding the other party’s interests and finding ways to align them with your own.

    This episode will show you how to save hundreds — or thousands — in your regular spending, simply by asking.

  • | | | | | | | |

    #542: Are We All Financial Hypochondriacs? Why We Feel Broke, Even When Our Bank Accounts Are Full

    Ever feel like you’re never doing enough with your money, even when your finances look good on paper? 

    You’re not alone. 

    Katie Gatti Tassin, host of the Money with Katie podcast, dives into a phenomenon called “money dysmorphia” in today’s interview.

    She shares how she got flooded with responses when she asked her listeners about money dysmorphia. Folks with hefty savings and investments still worry they’re not doing enough. It’s like they’re always waiting for the other shoe to drop.

    Where does this come from? Katie points to a few culprits. Social media is an obvious scapegoat. But traditional media plays a role too. Think about all those TV shows where “normal” families live in massive houses and drive fancy cars. It skews our perception of what’s average.

    Location matters too. Katie talks about how moving from Dallas to Fort Collins changed her spending habits. Different cities have different vibes and social norms around money.

    The conversation takes an interesting turn when Katie shares her own experience buying a Porsche. She felt conflicted, worried her FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) community would judge her. It highlights how even personal finance experts grapple with these issues.

    They also touch on how the pandemic shook up financial priorities. When faced with uncertainty, some people realized saving for a far-off future might not be the only goal worth pursuing.

    Katie and Paula discuss the importance of balance. It’s good to save, but not at the expense of living your life now. They suggest seeking out voices in the personal finance world to get a more rounded perspective.

    Travel comes up as a way to gain financial perspective. Seeing how people live in other parts of the world can make you appreciate what you have or show you where your own country could improve.

    Katie and Paula offer food for thought on how to navigate our complex relationship with money. It’s a conversation that might make you think differently about your own financial mindset.