#768: Q&A: Her Parents Give Her $38,000 a Year. Should She Quit Her Job?
“Gifts from my parents are out of my control.”
That line came from a listener’s voicemail, and it’s the smartest way I’ve heard anyone think about financial help from parents.
Her parents have close to $10 million and plan to give her and her brother up to $38,000 a year in financial help while they’re still alive. Meanwhile, she’s burned out at work, and she and her wife plan to have kids within the next two years.
So should she count on that financial help from parents and quit her job to stay home? Joe and I say yes, as long as she has a plan B. We talk about multiple exit strategies, keeping a toe in the water in her industry, and why staying connected also makes her a stronger job candidate if the financial help from her parents ever stops.
Then we look at financial help from parents from the other side: Tim wants to pay for his kids’ college with a $165,000 inherited IRA, and he’s trying to decide where to keep the money in the meantime. We close with Jeff, who wants to know whether his backdoor Roth contributions could hurt his family’s FAFSA results.
Listener Questions
The questions we answered this episode
+
Listener Questions
Anonymous (let’s call them “Emily”) asks: Would it be a mistake to count on money from my parents when making a long-term financial plan?
My parents are in a very fortunate situation with a paid-off house, long-term care insurance, and close to $10 million in net worth. Their stated goal is to gift money to my brother and me during their lifetimes using the IRS annual gifting limit rather than leaving it as an inheritance after they die.
Meanwhile, my wife and I live in a high-cost-of-living area with a pretty hefty mortgage payment, and we’re planning to have kids in the next two years. I’m currently burnt out at my job and have been considering taking a sabbatical to be a stay-at-home parent, but our current lifestyle would be tight on just my wife’s salary. If we receive regular cash infusions from my parents, that shortfall would be covered, leaving our investments to keep growing undisturbed.
On paper, it sounds like the perfect solution: my parents get to space out their inheritance, I get to stop working, and my wife doesn’t have to live on rice and beans just to avoid daycare bills. However, I’ve watched friends struggle to find work even without resume gaps, and I worry that accepting this generosity now could put me in a precarious position if I need to re-enter the job market after years of being a stay-at-home parent.
I really don’t want to keep working if I don’t have to, but gifts from my parents are out of my control. How can I live like the money is going to be there while still being able to pivot if someday it isn’t?
Tim asks: I’m 48 years old, on track with my retirement savings, have no debt other than our mortgage, and I’m overall in a comfortable place financially. I recently inherited $165,000, which is in an inherited IRA. My wife and I have two kids, ages 15 and 12, and I intend to use this money to pay for college.
I plan to draw down the money steadily over the 10-year withdrawal period and am exploring the options of either a high-yield savings account or a CD ladder for the money once it’s withdrawn. My question is where I should keep the money while it’s still in the IRA.
I know that with a short-term window, I don’t want to be in equities. Based on past shows, I’m looking at Ginnie Maes as a possible place to keep it. Is that appropriate for this timeframe? I’ll start withdrawing the money in 2027 and will need to begin using it in four years when my son goes to college. I’m uncertain about the balance of the money that will sit for five to 10 years. Are Ginnie Maes a good option for that timeframe? I sold out of the funds that my father kept this money in, and it’s sitting in a money market account right now. What are the best options for this scenario?
Jeff asks: I’m from West Virginia and have a follow-up question regarding college financial aid based on your response in episode 760. In that episode, you advised listeners to be mindful of IRA distributions and how they impact financial aid since they are counted as income.
Our kids are in 9th and 5th grade, so we are rapidly approaching the financial aid window and will be in it for eight years. While I’m not taking any true distributions, I do backdoor Roth contributions every year, and on paper, the 1099-R forms show a distribution from the traditional IRA.
When researching how backdoor Roth contributions affect the FAFSA and other financial aid, the best information I found indicated that the IRS link prefilling the FAFSA may count that transaction as income, which might require a manual override if that’s even allowed. It’s unclear whether I can make that adjustment myself or if the school would have to do it after submission, and relying on adjustments on the back end seems impractical.
Since our kids are four years apart, we’ll be navigating the financial aid process for eight-plus years if they both go to college. I don’t want to give up years of Roth contributions just to potentially qualify for an unknown amount of aid, but knowing whether backdoor Roth contributions will impact our FAFSA results will help guide my decisions. Do you have any guidance on this?
Key Takeaways
The biggest ideas from the conversation
+
Key Takeaways
- Treat financial help from parents as plan A: Counting on financial help from parents isn’t automatically a mistake. It’s fine to build a plan around that money, as long as there’s a plan B, C and even D ready if the gifts stop or gift tax laws change.
- Keep a toe in the water professionally: If you step away to be a stay-at-home parent, stay connected: freelance or consult a little, go to a conference or two a year, take classes, and write about your field. That keeps your network warm and builds savings at the same time.
- Your backup plan doubles as career insurance: The side work that keeps you employable also pads your savings. If the financial help from parents ever dries up, that cushion buys you time to figure out your next move, and you’ll re-enter the job market as a stronger candidate.
- Generous parents should secure their own future first: Parents who give financial help while they’re alive get to watch it change their family’s life. But long-term care costs late in life are hard to predict, so it’s wise to have 1.5 to 2 times what you’ll need before gifting.
- For short-term college money, start with I bonds: For money needed within a few years, like Tim’s college fund, I bonds are a strong first choice for the first $10,000 a year. Beyond that, Ginnie Maes, T-bills and laddered CDs carry similar risk and similar yields, so the choice between them barely matters.
- Backdoor Roth contributions shouldn’t hurt your FAFSA: Because the traditional IRA contribution is non-deductible, converting it to a Roth creates little or no taxable income. Leave it in cash for about 24 hours before converting, and make sure the FAFSA reports it as a rollover, not an untaxed distribution.
Resources
Links, tools and references mentioned
+
Resources
Paying for college in 3 years?
Match every dollar to when you’ll need it, on one free page.
affordanything.com/cornerstone
Current I bond rates
From TreasuryDirect.
treasurydirect.gov
Stacking Benjamins
Joe’s show. Search “charitable giving” to find the episode he mentioned.
stackingbenjamins.com
Daffy
The giving platform Joe discussed.
daffy.org
Episode 760
The earlier episode Jeff refers to in his question, which covered how IRA distributions can affect financial aid.
affordanything.com/episode760
Chapters
Jump to a specific part of the conversation
+
Chapters
Note: Timestamps are approximate and may vary across listening platforms due to dynamically inserted ads.
| 6:12 | Should you count on $38,000 a year from your parents? |
| 16:49 | How to stay hireable through a multi-year career break |
| 22:53 | Why giving while you’re alive beats leaving an inheritance |
| 25:25 | How much parents need before gifting money to kids |
| 33:43 | Where to keep money you’ll spend within 10 years |
| 39:00 | Why a “safe” bond fund lost 11% in 2022 |
| 42:15 | Why Joe picks government savings bonds right now |
| 51:52 | Why the “best” safe option barely matters here |
| 1:00:08 | Will a Roth workaround hurt your kids’ financial aid? |
| 1:03:59 | The financial aid form mistake to avoid |
Sponsors
Sponsors supporting this episode
+
Sponsors
Give the gift of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers, or go to Quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK, too.
Ready to clean out your closet and make some extra money? Download the Vinted app for free and start listing. With no seller fees, you keep every dollar you earn.
With Policygenius, you can find 20-year life insurance policies starting at just $276 a year for $1 million in coverage. Head to policygenius.com to compare life insurance quotes from top companies and see how much you could save.
Spend less time searching, and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes — less stress, less time, more results. When you need the right person to cut through the chaos, this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Listeners of this show get a $75 Sponsored Job credit to help get your job the premium status it deserves at Indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply.
Got a money question on your mind? Submit it here and it could be featured on an upcoming Q&A episode.
